Episode 52: Commonly Missed Uncommon Orthopedic Injuries


We rarely discuss medico-legal issues on EM Cases because it misguides us a bit from good patient centered care – which is what emergency medicine is really all about.

Nonetheless, missed orthopedic injuries are the most common reason for an emergency doc to be sued in Canada. This is partly because missed orthopedic injuries are far more common than missed MIs for example, but it’s also because it’s easy to miss certain orthopedic injuries – especially the ones that aren’t super common. And orthopedics is difficult to learn and remember for the EM practitioner as there are so many injuries to remember.

And so, you guessed it – on this episode we’re going to run through some key not-so-common, easy to miss orthopedic injuries, some of which I, personally had to learn about the hard way, if you know what I mean.

After listening to this episode, try some cognitive forcing strategies – for every patient with a FOOSH that you see, look for and document a DRUJ injury. Wait, hold on….I don’t wanna give it all away at the top of the post.

Let’s hear what EM doc and sports medicine guru Ivy Cheng, and the orthopedic surgeon who everyone at North York General turns to when they need help with a difficult ortho case, Hossein Medhian, have to say about Commonly Missed Uncommon Orthopedic Injuries.

Written Summary & Blogpost written and prepared by Keerat Grewal and Anton Helman, Oct 2014

Quick Reference Cards for each injury discussed in this episode (click on card to view pdf)

Lisfranc

Ch1 Lisfranc Injuries

Ch2 Perilunate

Ch 2 Perilunate Injuries

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Ch3 DRUJ injuries

Ch3 DRUJ injuries

Ch4 Pelvic Apophyseal Injuries

Ch4 Pelvic Apophyseal Injuries

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Lisfranc Injuries – Commonly Missed Uncommon Orthopedic Injuries

Lisfranc injuries are a spectrum of injuries, from a simple sprain to complete disruption of the tarso-metatarsal joints in the midfoot. These typically occur at the base of the 2nd metatarsal. Lisfranc injuries are easy to miss because they are very uncommon and because the x-ray findings are often subtle or even absent on standard views. Low velocity injuries are typically more commonly missed than high velocity ones. It’s these subtle, low velocity injuries that we should be on the look out for.

Lisfranc-commonly-missed-uncommon-orthopedic-injuries

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The usual mechanism of injury for a Lisfranc is plantar flexion with external rotation of the ankle. A classic example is a fall from a horse with the foot caught in the foot stirrup. Other examples include: MVC, foot planted in hole, awkward step off of a curb. In children, a classic history for a Lisfranc injury is the “bunk bed fracture” where a child leaps onto a bunk bed, landing on their toes with an axial load on a plantar flexed ankle.

Patients are typically unable to weight bear. A key clinical clue is a hematoma/ecchymosis on the plantar aspect of the foot. Commonly, there is significant dorsal midfoot swelling.

Lisfranc-plantar-echymosis

 

 

 

 

 

 

Look for signs of compartment syndrome, which may include: parasthesias or hyperesthesia, particularly in the first dorsal webspace.

For more on compartment syndrome see Episode 28 on Vascular Catastrophes with Anil Chopra and David Carr. 

Commonly, patients have a normal-appearing x-ray. Obtain 3 views of the foot (AP, lateral and standard 45 degree oblique views). Normally on the AP x-ray, the medial edge of the base of the 2st metatarsal should line up with the medial edge of the medial cuniform. On the oblique x-ray, the medial edge of the 3rd and 4th metatarsals should line up with the medial edges of the middle and lateral cuniforms.

normal-Lisfranc-alignment

Normal alignment of 2nd metatarsal on AP view

normal-alignment-Lisfranc-oblique

Normal alignment of the 3rd and 4th metatarsals on the oblique view

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Common x-ray findings include:

  1. Widening – look for widening between the bases of the 1st and 2nd or 2nd and 3rd metatarsal bases. Widening >2mm is an indication for urgent surgical intervention.
  1. Any fracture or avulsion – look for a ‘fleck sign’, which is pathognomonic for a Lisfranc injury. This is a small bony fragment avulsed from the second metatarsal base or medial cuniform.
Lisfranc-Fleck-Sign-commonly-missed-uncommon-orthopedic-injuries

Lisfranc ‘Fleck Sign’ – avulsion fracture

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Obtain a 30 degree oblique x-ray – this eliminates overlap of metatarsals.

Consider weight-bearing stress views, following an ankle nerve block.

Consider a CT of the foot if the x-rays still do not show an injury and you remain suspicious.[/wpspoiler][wpspoiler name=”Question 6: What is the appropriate ED management for a patient with a Lisfranc injury?”]

For an undisplaced or suspected injury without radiographic findings, place the patient in a posterior back slab. Patients should be non-weight bearing, and outpatient follow up should be arranged with orthopedics. Discharge instruction should include elevation of the leg, and warning signs of compartment syndrome of the foot.

In a significantly displaced injury or dislocation (>2mm widening at the Lisfranc joint) – immediate orthopedics referral in the ED is required for urgent surgical intervention.

Perilunate Injuries –
Commonly Missed Uncommon Orthopedic Injuries

The spectrum of perilunate injuries that usually result from a FOOSH mechanism, range from the least significant scapholunate dissociation to the most significant lunate dislocation:

  1. Scapho-lunate dissociation – a ligamentous injury with minimal clinical findings and a gap on the AP x-ray of the wrist between the scaphoid and the lunate (The Terry Thomas, or David Letterman or Madonna sign); this the most common cause of SLAC (scapholunate advanced collapse).
  2. Perilunate dislocation – with advancement of injury, the capitate dislocates from the lunate fossa.
  3. Lunate dislocation occurs with further advancement of this injury, which is a volar dislocation of the lunate out of the ‘seat’ of the capitate.
Swelling and deformity are often absent on exam. The x-ray findings can be very subtle.
  1. On the AP x-ray of the wrist, think of carpal bones as flagstones that should have equal distances of 1-2mm between them. Any narrowing/overlap or widening between carpal bones should make you suspicious of a serious perilunate ligamentous injury. If you can’t ‘drive a car around the bones’ then you should suspect a perilunate injury.
  1. There are typically 3 smooth Gilula lines, which form arcs between the rows of carpal bones. These lines should be smooth, if there any steps or disruption of these lines, you need to consider a perilunate ligamentous injury.

Gilula-lines

Gilula-lines on a normal AP x-ray of the wrist – any disruption in these lines should raise your suspicion for a ligamentous injury

 

 

A gap between the scaphoid and lunate on the AP x-ray of the wrist of >3mm is a scapholunate dissociation until proven otherwise. This x-ray finding has been described as The Terry Thomas Sign or The David Letterman Sign as well as The Madonna Sign as all 3 of these famous entertainers have an obvious gap between their two front teeth.

terry-thomas-sign-commonly-missed-uncommon-orthopedic-injuries

Terry Thomas or David Letterman or Madonna sign – a gap between the scaphoid and lunate on the AP view of the wrist indicating a scapholunate dissociation

On the AP x-ray of the wrist, there is crowding of the carpal bones such that the normal 1-2mm of space in between the carpal bones is lost in both perilunate and lunate dislocations. Sometimes a triangular appearing lunate will be found in a lunate dislocation.

On the lateral x-ray, there should be normal ‘stacking of cups’. The radius, capitate, and base of metacarpals are all look like cups and should stack on top of each other in a straight line. Assess the radio-lunate-capitate line, a vertical line through the radius, which should normally bisect the capitate. If there is not normal stacking, consider a perilunate dislocation. With further displacement of the lunate out of the seat of the capitate, the lunate appears like a ‘spilled tea cup’ and then is classified as a complete lunate dislocation.

stacking-cups

‘Stacking of cups’ alignment of radius, capitate, lunate and 2nd metacarpal on normal lateral x-ray of the wrist

spilled-teacup

The ‘spilled tea cup’ appearance of a lunate dislocation

 

 

 

There can be long-term functional disability and pain. There is a significant risk of median nerve palsy, pressure necrosis, compartment syndrome and long-term wrist dysfunction.

clinical pearl

Clinical Pearl

 

 

A FOOSH injury + acute carpal tunnel syndrome = perilunate dislocation until proven otherwise

Reduction of a perilunate dislocation is a simple procedure that can and should be done by the ED physician in the ED. The elbow is flexed to 90 degrees and hand placed in finger traps. 10-15lbs of longitudinal traction is applied for 10 min. With a dorsal dislocation, the wrist is initially extended and traction is applied. The wrist is then flexed with volar pressure applied to the lunate. A palpable clunk may be perceived.

perilunate-dislocation-reduction

Reduction technique of perilunate dislocation

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Post-reduction, these patients should be placed in a volar slab, in neutral position to avoid median nerve damage.

If adequate anatomical reduction is achieved, these patients require close orthopedics follow up in 1-2 days for possible operative management.

For more on periluate and lunate dislocations visit Sinai EM

Distal Radius Ulnar Joint (DRUJ) Injuries

After a FOOSH, either in isolation or associated with a wrist fracture, pain that is predominantly over the distal ulna is a DRUJ injury until proven otherwise.

Be suspicious of a DRUJ dislocation if:

  1. The ulnar styloid is more or less prominent on the affected wrist or looks displaced.
  2. You may feel crepitus and/or blocking on pronation or supination of the wrist.
  3. You may feel the ‘piano key’ sign, which is the ability to ballot the ulnar styloid.
  4. Look for the ulnar fovea sign, which is point tenderness over the ulnar capsule, palmar to the extensor carpi ulnaris tendon.
ulnar-fovea-sign

Ulnar Fovea Sign in DRUJ injuries

The spectrum of DRUJ injuries range from a simple sprain to a complete dislocation of the joint. DRUJ injuries are commonly associated with a FOOSH injury, with or without distal radius fractures. DRUJ injuries can also occur with other carpal injuries. In a patient with a suspected DRUJ injury, rule out a radial head fracture at the elbow.
On the AP x-ray of the wrist, look for widening of the joint > 2mm. On the lateral x-ray, look for displacement or subluxation of the distal ulna compared to the distal radius. The majority of DRUJ dislocations are dorsal.
The majority of DRUJ subluxations or dislocations are dorsally displaced. In these cases, supination and pressure over the ulnar head typically reduces this injury. Post-reduction, place the patient in an above elbow splint in supination similar to the way you would immobilize a patient with a Smith’s fracture.

Pelvic Apophyseal Avulsion Fractures

Epiphyseal plates and apophyses are the weakest part of the MSK chain. Because ligaments and tendons are stronger than these bony growth areas in children and young adults, avulsion fractures of these areas can occur in patients under the age of 25. The mechanism of injury is typically a sudden or forceful eccentric muscle contraction during running, jumping or kicking, and so these are usually sports-related injuries.

Q: What are the common sites affected by pelvic apophyseal avulsion fractures?

The ischial tuberosity is the most common site of a pelvic apophyseal avulsion fracture that results from a sudden contraction of the hamstring muscle.

pelvic-apophyseal-avulsion-commonly-missed-uncommon-orthopedic-injuries

Ischial pelvic apophyseal avulsion fracture

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Other Pelvic Apophyseal Injuries include:

These avulsion fractures take longer to heal compared to a simple strain (can take up to 6-8 weeks). Commonly, management is initiated with non-weight bearing ambulation with crutches, then weaning as tolerated.

 

For more commonly missed orthopedic injuries on EM Cases Episode 1 Occult Fractures and Dislocations and Episode 58 Tendon and Ligament Commonly Missed Uncommon Orthopedic Injuries

 

Dr. Helman, Dr. Mehdian and Dr. Cheng and no conflicts of interest to declare.

Key References

  1. Anderson, RB, Hunt, KJ, & McCormick, JJ. Management of common sports-related injuries about the foot and ankle. 2010. J Am Acad Orthop Surg, 18(9): 546-56. Abstract
  1. Caswell, F & Brown C. Identifying foot fractures and dislocations. 2014. Emerg Nurse, 22(6): 30-4. Abstract
  1. Stanbury, SJ & Elfar, JC. Perilunate dislocation and perilunate fracture-dislocation. 2011. J Am Acad Orthop Surj, 19(9): 554-562. Abstract
  1. Boyd, KT, Peirce, NS, & Batt, ME. Common hip injuries in sport. 1997. Sports Med, 24(4): 273-88. Abstract
  1. Moeller, JL. Pelvic and hip apophyseal avulsion injuries in young athletes. 2003. Curr Sports Med Rep, 2(2): 110-5. Abstract

For more on Orthopedic Pearls & Pitfalls download our free interactice eBook EM Cases Digest Vol.1 MSK & Trauma

em cases digest

By | 2017-02-16T11:05:35+00:00 October 13th, 2014|Categories: EM Cases, Emergency Medicine, Episodes, Orthopaedics, Trauma|Tags: , , , , , |3 Comments

Sign up for our Newsletter 

About the Author:

Dr. Anton Helman is an Emergency Physician at North York General in Toronto. He is an Assistant Professor at the University of Toronto, Division of Emergency Medicine, the Education Innovation Lead at the Schwartz-Reisman Emergency Medicine Instititute and is on the advisory board of The Teaching Institute. He is the founder and host of Emergency Medicine Cases.

3 Comments

  1. Dr Safa Kaftan October 16, 2014 at 5:27 am - Reply

    i am so ever grateful to you for the great work

  2. Sean O'Sullivan May 7, 2015 at 6:19 pm - Reply

    This MSK episode was just great. Precisely the kind of info on these zebras that we need to bring them into our awareness and great detail on mechanisms and management. It certainty elevated my understanding of Lisfranc, as it had been my impression that this was a rare injury, requiring a considerable force, usually occurring when a driver hits something hard with the foot jammed on the brakes.
    Lisfranc, as I am sure everyone knows, was Napoleon’s physician, and the metatarsal/tarsal joint was where he performed his eponymous front foot amputations (with an axe) on those soldiers unfortunate enough to have stepped on a piece of exploding ordinance.
    Great work guys. We in ER practice are indebted to the entire team.

  3. […] EM Cases: Missed Ortho Injuries […]

Leave A Comment